Thursday, October 14, 2010

the new plan

It turns out that Lily's a lot more enjoyable to be around these days. It also turns out that it was me, not her, that changed. I don't know how to explain the change without just telling a couple of stories about how things go these days compared to how they would have gone in the past.

Mornings around here used to be a battle zone. Even after I changed my mindset a bit, it is still stressful to get three young children dressed and fed and out the door on time. The way mornings used to work was I had a list of five things I needed Lily to do in the mornings. They had to be done in my order, on my watch and without a fight. If she got them done quickly, and the way I said they needed to be done, then she would get to watch TV for a few minutes before school. Needless to say, the TV hasn't been on on any school morning since school started. That's just how good things were going during our morning routine. There was screaming, crying, fighting with siblings and running around like chickens with our heads cut off. Not good.

Here's how I changed my approach: Instead of telling Lily exactly what to do and when to do it, I asked her how we could make mornings go better for everyone. She had quick and logical responses. She wanted to eat breakfast in her pajamas and take things slower in the morning. "I don't like to hurry, Mommy." I can totally relate! I am slow to wake up and would love to roll out of bed and eat me breakfast first thing. So, we solved the problem together. I told her that if she was going to eat breakfast first thing, then she needed get ready for school without stalling so that we didn't run out of time to get everything done. We also decided that we would get up 15 minutes earlier in the mornings so we had time to take things a bit slower.

The first morning of our plan went pretty well. She woke up first thing to have her breakfast, but she was annoyed that Drew was at the table with her. Instead of demanding that she sit there and be nice to her brother, I asked her how we could solve this problem so everyone could be happy. She solved the problem on her own again. She asked to eat her breakfast alone in her art area. Now, old me would have not even thought of solving the problem this way, let alone with her help! But, it worked magically. She now eats her breakfast alone in her pj's with nary a tear or grumble.

The second morning of our new approach Lily did just fine until it was time to put on her school shoes. She was fighting me and my frustration level was rising quickly. At some point I realized that things were getting out of hand and that I had not asked her what the problem was. Instead I was just demanding she do it my way. And, RIGHT NOW! So, I stopped and calmed down. Then I asked her what the deal was. Why wasn't she getting her shoes on for school? Her answer was simple. Some of the girls at school wear their fancy shoes to school and bring their tennis shoes in their backpacks for PE. Ah-ha! Old me would have stuffed her feet in her shoes and drug her kicking and screaming to school. Bad start. Bad mommy. Obviously we packed her tennis shoes up and she wore her fancy rain boots to school. Problem solved, no tears.

There has been a shift in our relationship. She is cooperating more easily. She works with me way more and understands that she has a voice. She now trusts that Mom will listen when she talks. She now sees that I am willing to work with her and take some extra time to make sure she gets what she needs.

So many of us are taught that children should do what their parents say because they said so. We learn that if you give in to your kid, or adjust in any way, that you are spoiling your child. We are told that if we collaborate with our child that our child will not know what it's like in the real world. They will fail as adults if we don't make them do what we say all the time. I have to wholeheartedly disagree with that. The real world is not a place that, as an adult, you can't negotiate and decide where and when to eat your breakfast. The real world doesn't have someone telling you to do something "because I said so". In the real world we are expected to make good choices, to work and play with fellow human beings; basically, to lead a happy and fulfilling life. We are not expected to do good things because we might get in trouble if we don't, we are expected to do things because it's the right thing to do.

This new way of parenting is going to take some work, but when was parenting not work? It's also going to take extra time to work things out. But, isn't that better than dragging your kicking screaming child around town demanding she do what you say RIGHT NOW! I like this new way of thinking and I'm pretty sure Lily's feeling good about it. You know how I know? Because, when I revert back to my old ways with her she says to me, "I don't like this solution! This doesn't work for me! We need to work together to come up with a better plan!" Now, who wouldn't be happy with a child that's willing to work with people and problem solve? I am giving my child confidence, a strong voice and a really good approach to building solid healthy relationships with others. This girl is a rock star!


Some of Lily's creativity made it to the benches in the kitchen. (The bench has now been removed!)


If anyone is interested in where I learned this new way of thinking, check out the book The Explosive Child. I think the ideas in this book have changed my whole parenting experience. Also, I am confident that you don't have to have an explosive child for this new way of thinking to be a positive thing at your house.

1 comment:

Dayna Richardson said...

Options and possibilities are always good.